|
If you are reading this review, then chances are you do not earn your
living in one of the professions that Barbara Ehrenreich assayed while
researching Nickel and Dimed. If you are only earning seven
dollars and change an hour, then odds are you trade off computer
ownership and Internet access in favor of things like food and
lodging. By the same token, if you are reading this review, then
chances are you are almost certainly beneficiary, either occasional or
daily, of the labors performed by Ehrenreich's contemporaries.
Nickel and Dimed represents her examination of the consequences
of welfare reform in the United States. She set out to learn how
people who make their living working at low wage, service-oriented
jobs — the sort of jobs champions of welfare reform usually tout
when they speak of job creation in the United States. To this end,
Ehrenreich decided to put herself in the shoes of the people —
and in her experience, these workers are primarily women —
trying to make ends meet on six to seven dollars and hour. Nickel
and Dimed recounts her experiences working as a waitress and hotel
housekeeper in Florida, a house cleaner and dietary aide in Maine, and
a Wal-Mart associate in Minnesota.
Ehrenreich established a series of parameters to structure her
experiment. At the most basic level, her goal was "to spend a month in
each setting and see whether I could find a job and earn, in that
time, the money to pay a second month's rent." Although limited
in scope, this decision reflects the fundamental challenge facing
low-wage workers in the United States. As she notes in the
introduction, "Almost anyone could do what I did — look for
jobs, work those jobs, try to make ends meet. In fact, millions of
Americans do it every day, and with a lot less fanfare and dithering."
Once she enters the low-wage workforce, the account of
Ehrenreich's experiences quickly takes on a Dickensian air.
While visions of Florida restaurants and Maine maid services
don't provoke the same visceral reaction as accounts of
nineteenth century London workhouses, the careful reader will note
certain similarities. At times, Nickel and Dimed reads as a
repetitive tale of long hours, tedious tasks, stress injuries and
petty-minded bosses. Whether Ehrenreich is waiting tables, cleaning
houses or returning discarded merchandise to its proper place on the
Wal-Mart floor, the nature of her labor doesn't change all that
much, and the rhythm of her writing reflects the similarities among
her various occupations. To her credit, she supplements the anecdotal
drudgery with copious statistical footnotes and insights about her
coworkers' little workplace rebellions, her employers'
charismatic appeal to the people they employ and her customers'
various failings and offhand cruelties.
|